A few months back I purchased a copy of Bob Cordery's Gridded Naval Wargames:
Not really being a naval wargame buff, I was, however, enthused by the simplicity of these rules; so I decided to give it a go. The rules are really written to play out late 19th and early 20th Century sea battles, but there is enough information for a good WW2 game.
I dug out my old 1/3000 scale ships that have never been used and decided to fight a limited action based upon the engagement between the Bismarck and Prinz Eugen against Hood and Prince of Wales.
The German ships are sailing on a south westerly course off the coast of Greenland, Prinz Eugen leading:
On the other side of the board, heading Northwest is Hood and Prince of Wales:
The two forces sight each other and Bismarck opens fire upon Hood with her main armament at extreme range:
Bismarck's 15" shells slam into Hood causing significant damage.
Both sides continue to close the range and the two British warships are able to engage with all of their main armament scoring a number of direct hits on Bismarck. In the same round Bismarck returns fire further damaging Hood.
In the next round the Germans turn to the east. This brings the guns of Prinz Eugen into range; her salvo causing some damage to Prince of Wales.
However, both British ships fire at Bismarck again. Having found the range the impact of around 20 shells has a catastrophic effect on Bismarck and she is forced to break off the action.
Covered by Prinz Eugen, Bismarck turns away to the North. Prinz Eugen fires again and scores a few hits on Hood. But, the concentrated fire of the two British battleships pounds Prinz Eugen to pieces. The German ship explodes and sinks:
Bismarck is now out of range and with Hood severely damaged the British break off the action. Prince of Wales shadows Bismarck, while Hood turns for home. The action ends as Bismarck slips away:
What fun. fast moving and easy to play. I initially thought Hood would sink and the outcome would reflect real events, but it was not to be.
Great report. I have the book and am looking forward to trying the rules.
ReplyDeleteMy first effort too. I might have a go with some destroyers next, with some close range action.
DeleteI bought Bob book when it came out, and all I have managed to do is construct a couple of shore guns. Oh, yes, and find all my (painted but never used) WW2 1:4800 scale warships - battleships, carriers, cruisers destroyers and a few merchant vessels so that I can put them all in one place... Maybe there's a blog post there...
ReplyDeleteGive it a go. The terrain is very simple to set up!!!
DeleteBob,
ReplyDeleteThe result seems to have been almost as decisive as the original battle even though the Prinz Eugen was sunk rather than HMS Hood. It certainly is closer to the result that the Royal Navy would have expected.
All the best,
Bob
If the truth be told, Hood was just one SP from having to withdraw, so it could have gone either way.
DeleteI refought this with General Quarters a few years ago. For some reason, the Bismark player thought it would be a walk-over and turned to close the range. The first salvo from PoW resulted in one hit and Bismark was vapourised in a magazine explosion. The rest of the game consisted of Eugen being battered into scrap as we brave British Tars laughed our socks off.
ReplyDeleteFrom my now limited experience it does seem that fortunes in sea wargaming can change very rapidly.
Delete